Skip to main content

Table 3 Food insecurity themes and corresponding items, India, 2000–2015

From: Internal validity and reliability of experience-based household food insecurity scales in Indian settings

Study

Setting

Language

Item (abbreviation)

% yes

Severity (s.e)

In-fit

Out-fit

Anxiety relating to food budget or food supply

 Nord [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Food bought didn’t last (food no last)

75.9

2.79 (0.16)

0.75

0.16

 Agrawal et al. [21, 22]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Food did not last and no money for more

51.7

4.80 (0.4)

0.77

0.56

Meerut/urban

Hindi

Food did not last and no money for more

74.5

5.25 (0.03)

0.60

1.11

 Chatterjee et al. [25]

Mumbai/urban

Hindi

Worried household wouldn’t have enough food

61.1a

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Worried food would run out

23.0

5.53 (0.21)

1.05

0.75

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Food stored ran out

18.8

6.44 (0.22)

1.30

0.46

 Chinnakali et al. [26]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Worried household would not have enough food

2.0a

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra State (yes/no)

Marathi, English

Worried household would not have enough food

42.1

3.24 (0.11)

1.29

4.50

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Worried household would not have enough food

1.56

1.78

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Worried household would not have enough food

34.1

3.80 (0.19)

0.92

0.89

Perceptions of inadequate food quality or quantity

 Nord et al. [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Couldn’t afford to eat balanced meals (balanced meal)

77.3

2.94 (0.17)

1.00

4.96

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Eat less than you felt you should (ate less)

48.2

5.50 (0.14)

1.11

3.07

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Child couldn’t have a balanced meal (child balanced)

56.7

3.56 (0.17)

0.94

0.24

 Pasricha et al. [24]

Rural Karnataka

Kannada

Same as above

 Agarwal et al. [21]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Could not afford to eat balanced meal

65.8

2.25 (0.46)

1.00

0.31

 Agrawal et al. [22]

Meerut/urban

Hindi

Could not afford to eat nutritious meal (nutritious)

84.2a

3.63 (0.03)

1.11

11.22

 UHRC [15]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Relied on only a few kinds of low-cost food to feed children

99.5a

Could not afford children a balanced meal

89.7a

Children not eating enough

83.6a

 Chatterjee et al. [25]

Mumbai/urban

Hindi

Eat the same foods daily

60.1a

Have to eat any type of food that you did not want (undesirable food)

57.6a

 Gupta et al. [17]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Relied on only a few kinds of low-cost food to feed children

39.7

   

Could not feed children a balanced meal

40.4

   

Children not eating enough

30.9

   

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Did you cook bhalo mondo (‘rich food’ such as shemai, paish or polao) (not as part of a festival day) (rich food)

81.6

0.48 (0.41)

1.02

5.00

Could not give children their preferred food and had to rely on only a few kinds of low-cost food (child preferred foodlow-cost food)

16.4

5.36 (0.30)

0.96

2.02

Children could not be given a varied and healthy diet (varied and healthy)

38.5

3.94 (0.35)

1.04

0.86

Children were not eating enough food

11.3

8.90 (0.33)

0.63

0.29

 Chinnakali et al. [26]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Not able to eat the kinds of foods you preferred

1.6

Have to eat a limited variety of foods

0.4

   

Have to eat some foods that you/they really did not want to eat

0.4a

   

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra state (only yes/no)

Marathi, English

Not able to eat the kinds of foods you preferred

36.6

4.25 (0.09)

0.88

5.99

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Not able to eat the kinds of foods you preferred

1.05

1.01

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra state (only yes/no)

Marathi, English

Have to eat a limited variety of foods

31.4

5.19 (0.09)

0.85

0.85

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Have to eat a limited variety of foods

0.91

0.90

IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra state (only yes/no)

Marathi, English

Have to eat some foods that you really did not want to eat

25.5

6.08 (0.09)

0.94

0.87

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Have to eat some foods that you really did not want to eat

0.91

0.84

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Not able to eat the kinds of foods you preferred

40.5 (65.5)a

3.16 (0.19)

1.36

1.47

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Have to eat a limited variety of foods

26.5 (67.8)a

4.59 (0.19)

0.88

0.74

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Have to eat some foods that you really did not want to eat

25.2 (63.2)a

4.74 (0.19)

0.97

0.89

Reported instances of reduced food intake or its consequences for adults

 Nord et al. [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Adults in your household ever cut the size of your meals or skip meals (adult cut/skip)

43.3

6.30 (0.12)

0.76

0.32

 Nord et al. [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Hungry but didn’t eat (hungry)

31.9

7.00 (0.11)

0.98

1.11

 Agrawal et al. [21]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Cut meal size or skipped meal

23.9

8.97 (0.52)

1.07

4.63

 Agrawal et al. [21]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Hungry but couldn’t afford food

14.7

11.98 (0.72)

1.00

0.19

 Agrawal et al. [21]

Meerut/urban

Hindi

Cut meal size or skipped meal

43.5

8.14 (0.03)

0.52

0.63

 Agrawal et al. [21]

Meerut/urban

Hindi

Slept hungry but did not eat

20.7

11.98 (0.04)

1.03

6.43

 Chatterjee et al. [25]

Mumbai/urban

Hindi

Eat less than you felt you should

46.3a

Adult in your household cut the size of your meals

48.4a

   

Skip some of your daily meals (skip meal)

30.1a

   

Food didn’t last and no money to buy more (no food)

34.0a

   

Hungry and you did not eat a meal

49.8a

Not eat for a whole day

19.1a

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Adults in your family couldn’t eat at least two square meals (full stomach meals) a day (two square meals)

16.4

6.90 (0.22)

0.80

0.62

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Personally eat less food so that there would be more for the rest of the family (ate less)

20.0

6.15 (0.22)

0.88

0.95

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Adults in your family skip entire meals

3.8

9.74 (0.30)

0.89

1.11

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Hungry but didn’t eat

2.4

10.87 (0.44)

1.05

0.26

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Adult lost weight

20.6

6.03 (0.22)

0.78

0.42

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Adults in your family not eat for a whole day

2.2

10.87 (0.44)

0.70

0.16

 Chinnakali et al. [26]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Have to eat a smaller meal than you felt you needed

0.4a

Have to eat fewer meals in a day

0.8a

   

No food of any kind to eat in your household

2.0a

Go to sleep at night hungry

0.4a

Go a whole day and night without eating anything

0.0a

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra State (yes/no)

Marathi, English

Have to eat a smaller meal than you felt you needed

20.3

6.90 (0.09)

0.62

0.37

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Have to eat a smaller meal than you felt you needed

0.67

0.52

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra state (yes/no)

Marathi, English

Have to eat fewer meals in a day

18.2

7.35 (0.09)

0.63

0.47

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Have to eat fewer meals in a day

0.68

0.53

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra State (yes/no)

Marathi, English

No food of any kind to eat in your household

12.2

8.65 (0.10)

0.86

0.92

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

No food of any kind to eat in your household

0.92

0.72

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra State (yes/no)

Marathi, English

Go to sleep at night hungry

7.7

9.97 (0.13)

0.85

7.04

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Maharashtra state (only yes/no)

Marathi, English

Go a whole day and night without eating

4.5

11.37 (0.18)

1.09

11.54

 IIPS-UNICEF [28]

Polytomous scale

No = 0, rarely = 1, sometimes/often = 2

Marathi, English

Go a whole day and night without eating

1.19

2.10

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Have to eat a smaller meal than you felt you needed

23.3 (59.8)

4.96 (0.19)

0.86

0.78

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Have to eat fewer meals in a day

19.6 (51.7)

5.45 (0.19)

0.88

0.76

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

No food of any kind to eat in your household

13.9 (47.3)

6.37 (0.20)

0.84

0.66

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Go to sleep at night hungry

12.1

6.75(0.20)

1.13

0.90

 IFPRI [27]

Odisha

Oriya

Go a whole day and night without eating

11.1 (31.8)

7.00

1.19

0.93

Reported instances of reduced food intake or its consequences for children

 Nord et al. [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Cut the size of any of the children’s meals/or ever skipped meals of children (child cut/skip)

14.2

8.04 (0.12)

0.86

1.95

 Nord et al. [11]

Odisha/rural

Oriya

Children ever not eat for a whole day (child whole day)

4.96

9.04 (0.16)

1.10

0.73

 UHRC [15]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Cut the size of children’s meals

64.7b

Children ever hungry but you just could not afford more food

63.4b

   

Children ever skip meals

34.1b

Frequency of skipping meals

31.1b

Child not eat for a whole day

0.0b

 Gupta et al. [17]

Delhi/urban

Hindi

Cut the size of children’s meals

8.5

Children hungry but could not afford food

5.6

Children ever skip meals

2.9

Frequency of skipping meals

1.6

Child not eat for a whole day

1.3

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Children in your family could not eat at least three square meals (full stomach meals) a day (child 3 square meals)

9.1c

9.66 (0.39)

1.25

5.37

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Skip child’s/any of the children’s meals

1.1c

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Child/children hungry but you just couldn’t afford more food

1.5c

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Children in the household lost weight/felt weak (child lost weight)

20.0c

7.14 (0.28)

0.71

0.46

 Maitra [30]

Kolkata/urban

Bengali

Child did not eat a whole day

0.75c

 Nord and Cafiero [29]d

India

Multiple

Child not given enough food because of lack of money or other resources

  1. aPercentage of affirmative responses to combined ‘sometimes + often’ follow-ups. All questions are followed by phrases such as ‘because of a lack of money or other resources’ or ‘because you didn’t have enough money to buy food/more’. The item ‘run out of food/run out/food no last’ to be included in the domain of ‘worry/anxiety’ in US HFSSM (18 or 6-item scale) and FIES GWP 2012; however, it represents a more severe food insecurity condition in the HFIAS and FIES GWP 2014
  2. bThe GWP 2014 had extended FIES (eight adult items) where the extension was to include ‘how often’ follow-up questions to the two most severe questions (‘hungry’ and ‘whole day’)
  3. cThe GWP 2012 data for FIES included seven questions that asked about food conditions among children aged 0–14 years in the household
  4. dThe GWP 2014 had two child items if child aged under-five lived in the household. Child items were for research purposes and not included in the scale. No child items are included in the GWP 2015 survey