Skip to main content

Table 4 Population increase (mean number of progeny for 4 jars ± SE) and damage parameters of Sitophilus zeamais on grains of three maize varieties admixed with NeemPro® and stored for 4 months under laboratory conditions and percentage of seed germination

From: Use of NeemPro®, a neem product to control maize weevil Sitophilus zeamais (Motsch.) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) on three maize varieties in Cameroon

Maize variety/content (g/kg)

Number of insects alive

Grain damage (%)

Weight loss (%)

Germination (%)

CLH103

 Malagrain

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

84.13 ± 1.24a

 0

669 ± 0a

113 ± 0a

99.99 ± 0.01a

0 ± 0b

 0.75

5 ± 5b

1 ± 1b

0.13 ± 0.13b

85.56 ± 2.94a

 1.5

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

86.67 ± 1.93a

 3

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

76.67 ± 1.93a

 6

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

82.22 ± 2.94a

 F value

86.63***

8607.81***

999.99***

218.06***

CMS8501

 Malagrain

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0b

86.41 ± 1.02ab

 0

748 ± 28a

106 ± 0a

99.94 ± 0.01a

0 ± 0c

 0.75

40 ± 20b

5 ± 2b

1.13 ± 0.44b

85.55 ± 2.22ab

 1.5

6 ± 6bc

1 ± 1bc

0.61 ± 0.61b

82.22 ± 2.94ab

 3

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0b

78.89 ± 5.56ab

 6

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0c

0 ± 0b

72.22 ± 294b

 F value

86.63***

970.42***

17674.85***

110.92***

SHABA

 

 Malagrain

0 ± 0d

0 ± 0b

0 ± 0b

57.73 ± 2.05c

 0

762 ± 66a

98 ± 0a

99.98 ± 0.01a

0 ± 0b

 0.75

476 ± 60a

81 ± 12a

58.31 ± 24.36a

26.67 ± 13.47ab

 1.5

135 ± 48b

28 ± 5b

5.85 ± 1.12b

37.78 ± 2.94a

 3

54 ± 21bc

12 ± 2b

1.54 ± 0b

33.33 ± 1.93a

 6

15 ± 11c

7 ± 3b

0.69 ± 0.29b

30 ± 3.33a

 F value

47.11***

44.29***

16.5***

6.27***

  1. Means in the same column for the same maize variety, followed by the same letter do not differ significantly at P = 0.05 (Tukey’s test); number of replicates: 4; *** P < 0.001; F value: a ratio of two variances—the “between group” variance and the “within-group” variance